With how the Buffalo Sabres' goaltending has struggled this season, it has made it even tougher to watch Devon Levi have the success he has with the Edmonton Oilers. However, his performance Saturday against the Carolina Hurricanes shows exactly why it was the right decision by Jarmo Kekalainen to trade him when he did.
The former Sabres' goalie finished the game allowing seven goals on 36 shots as the Oilers lost 7-4. One of those goals was about as bad as fans will see an NHL goalie allow, as Sean Walker would beat Levi five-hole from center ice.
Sean Walker from the center ice logo?
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) November 21, 2026
Sean Walker from the center ice logo! pic.twitter.com/9Vf7VAuZ7M
Buffalo Sabres were not in a position to rely on an unproven goalie this season
The Sabres would trade Levi, along with a 2028 seventh-round pick, for a 2028 third-round pick during the summer. Levi was coming off a season in which he spent the entire time in the AHL with Rochester and had a solid season with a save percentage of .904 and a goals against average of 2.83.
Unfortunately, the problem for the Buffalo Sabres was that it was not dominant enough to warrant surpassing any of the goalies they had last season in Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen, Alex Lyon, and Colten Ellis.
This was the second game this season that Levi has allowed seven goals in a game and the reason he is 10-3-0 is because he has skaters like Connor McDavid having historic seasons in front of him. When considering how the Sabres' skaters have played this season, it is highly unlikely that Levi would have had the success he did in Edmonton if he had remained in Buffalo.
It certainly was easy to question the decision to trade Devon Levi this summer, especially with how Buffalo started. It is also not to say that this one goal or one game makes him a bad goalie or that he won't be successful in the NHL. In the playoffs, Luukkonen had a very similar goal that he allowed, where it was shot from center ice and bounced past him.
However, when evaluating the trade of Levi, it has to be looked at through the lens of where the Sabres were at the time. They were in the process of chasing Connor Hellebuyck, but if they didn't get him, it was tough to move off a veteran and go with an unproven prospect. It is not a given that they will be able to do it, and the Sabres are seeing that right now as they try to have some of their younger prospects replace the production lost by Alex Tuch.
It is a move that is always going to be scrutinized and when Levi has great games, fans will still point to it being a mistake. However, there was a reason he could not establish himself on the Sabres' roster and these games are a perfect example why.
