Sabres Need Superstar To Have Chance At Cup


Recently The Hockey News had a poll, asking readers who the best player in the NHL is. Now, while it’s no surprise that no Buffalo Sabres players were on that list, it did get me thinking of the past five Stanley Cup winners, and how many of these players did/do these champions possess. So, after the jump, let’s look at that list and gawk with jealousy, shall we?

This is The Hockey News list:

 Sidney Crosby 

 Pavel Datsyuk 

 Claude Giroux 

 Steven Stamkos 

 Jonathan Toews 

 Evgeni Malkin 

 Nicklas Lidstrom 

 Alex Ovechkin 

 Daniel Sedin 

 Zdeno Chara 

 Henrik Sedin 

 Shea Weber 

 Henrik Lundqvist 

 Tim Thomas 

 Martin St-Louis 

 Phil Kessel 

 Pekka Rinne 

 Jaromir Jagr 

 Corey Perry 

 Henrik Zetterberg 

 Nicklas Backstrom 

 Erik Karlsson 

 Drew Doughty 

 Joe Thornton 

 Ryan Getzlaf 

 Jarome Iginla 

 Ilya Kovalchuk 

 Brad Richards 

 Zach Parise 

 Anze Kopitar 

Now let’s look at the last five Stanley Cup winners, and the following players these teams possess from the list above:

Boston Bruins: Tim Thomas, Zdeno Chara

Chicago Blackhawks: Jonathan Toews

Pittsburgh Penguins: Evgeni Malkin, Sidney Crosby

Detroit Red Wings: Henrik Zetterberg, Pavel Datsyuk

Anaheim Ducks: Ryan Getzlaf, Corey Perry

See a pattern here? Each of these teams have at least one or two dominant players, players considered superstars by league standards. Every one of these players, except for the two Bruins, were drafted by each of these clubs. Toews, Malkin, and Crosby were all top-5 picks in their respective draft years, while Getzlaf and Perry were lower first-round picks.

Looking again at that list, would you, as a Buffalo Sabres fan, take anyone from the current roster and insert him in with that bunch? Two years ago, Ryan Miller would have already been included. Not anymore. Thomas Vanek? Maybe top-50. Jason Pominville? Perhaps if it were a top-100 list. Tyler Myers? Once he starts to show some real consistency, perhaps.

What the Sabres need is a bona-fide superstar. Whether it’s through a trade, free-agent signing or the draft, Buffalo is in short supply of being able to dress any one player on a nightly basis that scares the bejeezuz out of their opposition. Imagine the game-planning that would have to go on if you added, say, a Toews, a Sedin or a Malkin to the Sabres lineup.

Zach Parise is an unrestricted free-agent this summer, and he would seriously add an element of scoring and competitiveness to Buffalo’s roster (and perhaps allow them to move a winger – Vanek, perhaps – to acquire that ever-elusive number one centerman this team is lacking), but there will be 29 other teams lining up to procure his services.

So, with that in mind, would it be such a bad thing if the Sabres were to finish in the bottom five in the league, heading into the 2012 NHL Entry Draft? One, the team would be guaranteed a chance in the NHL Draft Lottery, putting them in the running for the number one pick overall. Two, any team picking in the top-five usually drafts a potentially great player, if not an impact player. Three, if the Sabres were actually picking a top two or three player, many times that player steps right into the NHL lineup in the upcoming season, and many do have an immediate impact. The top prospects eligible for the 2012 draft can be viewed here, and there are more than a handful of top-end studs to be had.

Obviously, if this year’s Sabres team has any form of competitive spirit (which is still up for debate), they are going to fight until the bitter end. There’s no guarantee where they’ll finish in the standings, and if they keep playing with the same urgency and intensity as they have displayed as of late, they may very well drop out of the top-five – or even top-ten – when it comes to seeding the teams on draft day.

As Sabres fans, we all want to cheer them to victory.

But, would it be such a bad thing if they started to slip again, and ended up with the chance to draft a superstar? It seems to me, if the organization truly does have dreams of winning “multiple Cups”, it’s better if they lose more than they win from here on out.

I’m only thinking of them.

Don’t forget about the OptionIt contest. All you have to do is register for free, indicate the Sabres as your favorite team, and you are entered to win tickets to the Sabres/Maple Leafs game on April 3rd.

  • Follow us on Twitter. In fact, don’t just follow us.  Follow who I follow and who follows me.  You’d be amazed at what you can learn about the Sabres, and how many laughs you can have. Oh, and that’s just @sabrenoise, also follow @dansterlace@Megan_Colleen_, and @Lardsy
  • Join us on Faceboook! Visit the SabreNoise Page or on the Network Blogs App.
  • Check out our main NHL site,  Too Many Men.  It’s a daily dose of hockey from around the league.
  • Have you heard Rink Side Rants yet?  It’s a weekly live podcast that airs on Sunday nights at 9 PM.  It’s like a fireside chat with me and Frank from The Rat Trick about hockey and whatever else is going on.
  • Interested in writing for SabreNoise?  Shoot me an email at  Another hockey team your forte?  Email  If it’s another sport you interested in writing about, will get you started.