Gavin McCarthy may receive his first cup of NHL coffee sooner than expected.
The 21-year-old defenseman, who grew up in the Buffalo suburb of Clarence Center, is making his presence felt in his first full season with the AHL's Rochester Americans. He was a third-round pick of the Sabres in the 2023 NHL Draft.
McCarthy is far from a finished product but he's already making noticeable strides with the Amerks after three years on pretty linear development at Boston University. He's racked up six points (one goal and five assists) across 13 appearances for Rochester this season.
"His game is in a good place right now," Americans head coach Michael Leone recently told Bill Hoppe of the Times Herald. "He's gapping. He's moving the puck quicker. I think that was the one thing, he was hanging onto too many pucks and not exiting the zone quick. But he's doing a great job for us right now."
The 6-foot-2 blueliner was always a steady presence defensively at BU, his improvement offensively over time has given him a clearer path toward the NHL.
McCarthy's recent strong play comes as the Sabres' third pair is struggling. Nobody from the group of Louis Crevier, Conor Timmins or Zach Metsa is playing well enough to warrant a full-time role, which is led to a rotation on the bottom pair.
Buffalo has also tried breaking up Owen Power and Olen Zellweger to create more balance, but so far that's only caused a dip in Zellweger's performance while playing with a member of that faltering trio.
Meanwhile, prized prospect Radim Mrtka, the No. 9 overall pick in the 2025 draft, still hasn't recorded his first point of the season for the Amerks in 16 games. It illustrates how much of his development curve remains despite the draft pedigree.
The Sabres do have some veteran options in Rochester (Dennis Gilbert, Caleb Jones and Jack Rathbone). They may be the preferred call-up options at the moment.
Yet, with Buffalo struggling to find any semblance of consistency, a player like McCarthy who's willing to throw his body around to create some energy could be valuable for a team that needs to find a spark in some way, shape or form.
It may not be imminent, but it'd no longer be a surprise if McCarthy ends up getting a few NHL games under his belt before the 2026-27 season wraps up.
Sabres' Lindy Ruff previously expressed confidence in Gavin McCarthy
The right-shot defenseman, a former member of the Buffalo Jr. Sabres development program, enjoyed an impressive training camp with the big club before getting sent to Rochester.
Informed by Hoppe that Sabres head coach Lindy Ruff pegged him as a future NHL player after camp, McCarthy responded: "Coming from him, he's a legend. So, if he sees that, it means a lot to me. It's just something I try to keep working for."
Again, this isn't a situation where the former BU captain is going to join the Sabres tomorrow and stay in the NHL for the remainder of his career. At this point, it's more of an emerging short-term option as the team tries anything to remain afloat in the competitive Eastern Conference.
McCarthy still has work to do before he's ready for a permanent NHL role. He's an efficient skater but the next step is more frequently turning defense into offense by leading transition breakouts, something that will be necessary to succeed in Ruff's system in Buffalo.
He'll also need to become more effective clearing out the top of the crease, an area the Sabres have failed miserably early this season. The promising prospect has no problem throwing his weight around in open ice, but those small-area battles are still a work in progress.
That said, he's trending in the right direction in the big picture. He's building a well-rounded, two-way game that gives him a real chance to become an NHL regular within the next handful of years.
McCarthy doing that for his hometown team would be a great story.
